PDA

View Full Version : SF restructure A teams from 6 to 5


Mike
28 June 2000, 12:48
Army Times 7/3/00, p. 22

Green Berets Restructure Skilled Soldier Shortage Depletes Elite 'A' Teams
By Matthew Cox

Struggling with an under-strength force, Army Special Operations Command has cut the number of Green Beret teams it can throw into a fight.

For more than a decade, Army Special Forces units have been losing skilled soldiers faster than it can replace them -- a problem that has forced many of its 12-man "A-teams" to operate at half strength.

As a temporary solution, the elite force has reorganized its company-level structure, manning each with five operational detachment A-teams (ODAs) instead of six.

The move leaves each of the five Special Forces Groups with nine fewer A-teams to deploy, but officials remain confident that full-strength teams are more likely to accomplish their mission.

"There were many ODAs that did not have enough people to do the missions expected of them, so they realigned to ensure that they have five fully manned [A-teams] per company," said Special Operations Command spokesman Maj. Jonathan Withington. "It gives us the flexibility to continue with our missions."

This redistribution of forces is part of a "get-well plan" begun a year ago to shore up the effectiveness of Special Forces units until the pipeline of newly trained Green Berets can be increased.

Special Forces recruits experienced officers, warrant officers and noncommissioned officers from all over the Army to conduct unconventional warfare operations in hot spots around the world.

A-teams operate behind enemy lines, conducting guerilla warfare missions and organizing and training civilian armies. Each Special Forces company also has one B-team, which specializes in mission planning.

But before soldiers can join a Special Forces unit, they must complete a grueling training program that can last up to a year, depending on the soldier's MOS.

The intensity of the training at the John F. Kennedy Special Warfare Center and School at Fort Bragg, N.C., means that an average of only 40 to 50 percent of soldiers who are accepted complete the Qualification Course, officials said.

This, combined with the prediction that 38 percent of the current Special Forces population will be eligible for retirement by the end of 2004, has prompted officials to rethink how Special Forces soldiers are trained to ensure more make it through the program.

While the training will remain the same, Special Forces units have reassigned 108 senior soldiers to the JFK center to serve as instructors.

"It improves the instructor-student ratio, which will, in turn, increase the production of students who are successful in the course," Withington said.

Officials maintain the reassignments will increase the instructor-to-student ratio at the Qualification Course to an average of one instructor for every 12 to 15 students, from the current ratio of one instructor for every 16 to 20 students.

Officials plan to evaluate the program's effectiveness in three years to see if Special Forces companies can return to operating with six A-teams.

"The bottom line is we have to increase production," Withington said. "This is a temporary solution until we get a fully manned force."

Tracy
28 June 2000, 13:00
I hate to say "I told you so..." but we saw this problem 10 years ago when the drawdown began.

The population of soldiers to recruit and draw from was smaller; but SOCOM insisted that they could INCREASE the size of SF.

We told the command group the only way to do that was to lower standards; which SWC did for a while until that backfired.

Now we're right back where we started from in 1975: Five teams to a company; with six teams' worth of gear. The more things change, the more they stay the same...

recce_o
28 June 2000, 13:51
If they are so hard up, why don't they issue a waiver so Canadians can join SF?!

Ranger002
28 June 2000, 13:56
Hey Tracy,

Do you remember the days back in the late 70's early 80's when there was talk of phasing out SF.
William

wolfhound227
28 June 2000, 16:34
Hey recce,

My old platoon Sargent was Canadian.
Last I heard ,he was in 10th group.
I don't know if he was born in the US
and then moved,but we called him
"The Caged Canadian"
because by the time he got to the 7th ID
he like an animal that had just escaped
from a zoo. http://www.specialoperations.com/ubboard/smile.gif

Mike
29 June 2000, 12:44
Tracy, maybe DOA can implement Eric Wendt's thesis, "Cohesion, longevity and cohort: improving the effectiveness of Special Forces ODAs." Naval Postgraduate School, 1995.

BTW,
I saw this abstract of Sean Feeley's thesis, "Special Forces assessment and selection."
(Naval Postgraduate School, 1998.
The purpose of this thesis is to evaluate the Special Forces Assessment and Selection (SFAS) program conducted by the U.S. Army's John F. Kennedy Special Warfare Center and School (SWCS). It seeks to determine the most accurate and relevant method of testing potential Special Forces soldiers and officers. Thesis study focuses on the validity of the current personal attributes required in a Special Forces soldier and the current testing methods employed to measure the required attributes set forth by SWCS. It also explores the issue of an additional selection program for the potential Special Forces officer. This study demonstrates that the current attributes required in the potential Special Forces soldier and officer are valid. However it recommends two additional attributes that will enhance the profile of the Special Forces soldier. It also demonstrates that the current testing methods of SFAS do not sufficiently test all the required attributes. This thesis recommends nine additional testing methods that adequately test all the required attributes for a Special Forces soldier and officer. This thesis focus on the assessment and selection program of SFAS; it does not discuss standards that must be achieved by the potential Special Forces soldier and officer."


[This message has been edited by Mike (edited 06-29-2000).]

recce_o
29 June 2000, 14:07
Hey Mike,

Do you know where the full text of the thesis can be found?

Mike
30 June 2000, 12:04
you can try through the interlibrary loan office of your local library (if you're nice to them and have patience) or order them through http://www.dtic.mil/stinet (if you're government or a government contractor go to DTIC, if not, go to www.ntis.gov) (http://www.ntis.gov))

SAPPER317
30 June 2000, 13:09
I went through the DTIC site and searched "Special Forces" and came up with a ton of documents. The thesis mentioned is at the top of the list; cost $7.00 for a copy.

SAPPER317

Spotlight_Ranger
2 July 2000, 23:09
Mike

Looking at the reading list you put in, let me assure you those authors (and I know) are to this day part of the problem, not the solution

Mike
3 July 2000, 12:01
That was I thought. DTIC used to put the resume (vita) of the authors but not anymore.

to recce-O and SAPPER317, if you click ont he DTIC's Full-Text Collection, there are 10+ reports relating to special forces that are full-text. Warning, they're PDF file and slow to download.